FANDOM


General
Meeting
General
Date: August 20, 2016
Location: ESB Chat
Host: AMK152
Chronology
Previous: December 28, 2014
Next: September 4, 2016
Table of meetings

The following is a summary of information surrounding a meeting that occurred on August 20, 2016.

ParticipantsEdit

AgendaEdit

  • 1. Chat
  • 2. Community
  • 3. User rights
  • 4. Policies
  • 5. Forums

VotingEdit

Question 1Edit

Question 1: "What does everyone think about requiring 50+ edits?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Jordan2001 (WC) User
Total: 5 0 0 5

Question 2Edit

Cans48: 0
TrevorOntartio719: 0-25
SonicTheEpic: 0
Squiddleward: 0
SBCA: 20
Depth Strider 10: 45
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls: 25
Jordan2001: 25-35
Nicko756: 10
Mb13566: 30
ZeoSpark: 0

Question 3Edit

Question 3: "What does everyone think about 25 edits as a voter requirement?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Jordan2001 (WC) User
SBCA (WC) Former Administrator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Total: 6 0 2 4

Question 4Edit

Question 4: "Edit requirements for voting: yes or no?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
Jordan2001 (WC) User
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
SonicTheEpic (WC) Adminstrator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
ZeoSpark (WC) Administrator
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
Mb13566 (WC) User
AW10 (WC) Administrator
Total: 12 0 1 11

Question 5Edit

Cans48: 0 total/0 main
Mb13566: 0 total/0 main
SpongeFreddy777: 100 total/50 main
Jordan2001: 50-100
TheOneFootTallBrickWall: 100
SBCA: Unknown/50 main
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls: 100 total/50 main

Question 6Edit

Question 6: "So for all users, what about 100 edits, 50 of them mainspace to qualify?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
Total: 5 4 0 1

Question 7Edit

Question 7: "For all promotion requests, should we require that users have a 1-month clean block record? Yes, no, higher or lower?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose ↑↑ ↓↓
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
Jordan2001 (WC) User
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
Total: 12 12 0 0 0 0

Question 8Edit

Question 8: "For promotion requests, should we require that user be on ESB at least 1 month in order to qualify?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Jordan2001 (WC) User
Mb13566 (WC) User
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
Total: 12 11 0 1

Question 9Edit

Question 9: "Should we require questions (different for each position) to be answered for all requests? Yes or no?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
Mb13566 (WC) User
Jordan2001 (WC) User
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
Spongebob456 (WC) Bureaucrat
AustinD-3 (WC) Administrator
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Total: 16 14 1 1

Question 10Edit

Question 10: "Should admin and bureaucrat requests require a 2 step process, concerns (5 days) and voting stage (7 days)?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Mb13566 (WC) User
AustinD-3 (WC) Administrator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
Jordan2001 (WC) User
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Total: 14 2 0 12

Question 11Edit

Question 11: "Should we lower the number of days for each stage? Or no 2-stage process?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose ↑↑ ↓↓
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Jordan2001 (WC) Administrator
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
Mb13566 (WC) User
AW10 (WC) Administrator
Spongebob456 (WC) Bureaucrat
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Total: 14 0 0 2 0 12

Question 11aEdit

Question 11a: "How about for admins and bureaucrats, 5 days for concerns and 5 days for voting?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Mb13566 (WC) User
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
Jordan2001 (WC) User
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Total: 11 0 2 9

Question 12Edit

Question 12: "Should we require all requests that a majority of bureaucrats must support in order for it to pass?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Mb13566 (WC) User
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
Jordan2001 (WC) User
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Spongebob456 (WC) Bureaucrat
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
Total: 16 14 2 0

Question 13Edit

Question 13: "Rename Moderator to Social Moderator, yes or no?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
Jordan2001 (WC) User
AW10 (WC) Administrator
Mb13566 (WC) User
TheOneFootTallBrickWall (WC) User
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
Total: 14 12 1 1

Question 14Edit

Question 14: "Should we raise the passing requirement for requests from 70% to 75%?"
User Status Support Neutral Oppose
Nicko756 (WC) Bureaucrat
TrevorOntario719 (WC) Chat moderator
SonicTheEpic (WC) Administrator
Cans48 (WC) Rollbacker
Jackninja5DipperGravityFalls (WC) User
SpongeFreddy777 (WC) Chat moderator
Jordan2001 (WC) User
FlyingDutchmen (WC) Rollbacker
Depth Strider 10 (WC) Assistant
ZeoSpark (WC) Bureaucrat
Mb13566 (WC) User
Squiddleward (WC) Administrator
Spongebob456 (WC) Bureaucrat
Dejavukitkat13 (WC) Former chat moderator
MightyMorphinJon (WC) Administrator
SBCA (WC) Former administrator
Total: 16 0 0 16

SummaryEdit

  1. Most users saw that trolls, drama, and badges were the biggest problem on the wiki.
  2. Underage law was considered to be changed. No consensus really came.
  3. A definition of trolling and drama is needed.
  4. The chat moderators are fine.
  5. An edit requirement for entering chat was considered.
  6. An overhaul to reporting was discussed, due to not many people using it. It was considered to be a feature of the chat bot.
  7. A solution to PM trolls was considered. However, nothing could be done.
  8. A discussion about ignoring trolls was started.
  9. A conflict resolution system was put to minimize drama.
  10. Assistant requests need more edits.
  11. 1 month requirement for voting.
  12. Voter points were considered depending on the user, but the idea was discarded.
  13. Voter fraud leads to 3 months of inability to request.
  14. Friend voting was discussed.
  15. Except for chat mod, you need 100 edits (50 mainspace) to request. You also need to be on ESB for 1 month, and a clean block record for 1 month.
  16. When making a request, you are asked questions.
  17. The majority of bureaucrats need to support a request for it to pass.
  18. Moderator is now Social Moderator.
  19. A modification of the percentage needed for a request to pass was considered.
  20. Time for discussions changed to 5 days concerns, 5 days voting.

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.